Medicare Advantage Plans in Shelby County, Illinois

41 Medicare Advantage plans are available in Shelby County for 2026. Compare premiums, benefits, and star ratings to find the best plan for you.

Plans Available

Avg. Monthly Premium

$12

Star Ratings

4.5-5.03

4.0-4.41

3.0-3.916

Benefits Breakdown

68%

Dental

68%

Vision

68%

Hearing

20%

Fitness

49%

OTC Benefit

15%

Transportation

Top 20 Plans

View all 41plans →

HumanaChoice Giveback H7617-013 (PPO)

Humana

4.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitnessOTC

Humana USAA Honor Giveback (PPO)

Humana

4.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitnessOTC

UHC Complete Care Support IL-1A (PPO C-SNP)

UnitedHealthcare

4.5

$15.2/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC IA-0002 (HMO-POS)

UnitedHealthcare

4.0

$55/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

Humana USAA Honor Giveback (PPO)

Humana

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitnessOTC

HumanaChoice Giveback H5216-403 (PPO)

Humana

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitnessOTC

Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO)

Aetna Medicare

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingTransport

Aetna Medicare Eagle (PPO)

Aetna Medicare

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTCTransport

AARP Medicare Advantage Patriot No Rx IL-MA01 (PPO)

UnitedHealthcare

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearing

Humana USAA Honor Giveback (Regional PPO)

Humana

3.5

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitness

HumanaChoice H5216-399 (PPO)

Humana

3.5

$18/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitness

Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO)

Aetna Medicare

3.5

$37/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTCTransport

AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC IL-6 (PPO)

UnitedHealthcare

3.5

$45/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

HumanaChoice R5361-002 (Regional PPO)

Humana

3.5

$103/mo

DentalVisionHearingFitness

Wellcare Simple Essential (HMO)

Wellcare

3.0

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

Wellcare Simple Essential Value (HMO)

Wellcare

3.0

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

Wellcare Giveback (HMO)

Wellcare

3.0

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearing

Wellcare Patriot Giveback (HMO)

Wellcare

3.0

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearing

HealthSpring True Choice (PPO)

HealthSpring

3.0

$0/mo

DentalVisionHearingOTC

Blue Cross Medicare Advantage Choice Premier (PPO)

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of IL, NM, OK, TX

3.0

$155/mo

DentalVisionHearing

View All 41 Plans in Shelby County

Compare Plans in Shelby County

Use our plan comparison tool to see detailed benefits, drug costs, and provider networks side by side.

Compare Plans

Find a Licensed Agent

Get free, personalized help from a licensed Medicare agent in Shelby County.

Find an Agent

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.

This is not a government website. This site is operated by Medicare Compare.